Tuesday 17 December 2013

Seerah of the Prophet s.a.w. - What a da'i can learn from him.

In the Name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Dispenser of Grace.

The last few days I have been battling an essay for my Seerah course.  While not the best work I have done, I thought I'd share it here as it falls nicely with the series on Seerah that I have been doing on and off.  I hope it will benefit someone.

Wassalam,
Sid

--------------------------------

The role of a da’i in today’s world is very challenging in the light of the mistrust by non-Muslims and the association of Islam with terrorism, whether justified or otherwise.  In this paper, we will explore the role of a da’i in this challenging environment and how we can learn from the example of Prophet Muhammad s.a.w. in this respect.  We will first define the role of the da’i and the challenges he/she faces.  The second part is focused on Prophet Muhammad in his role as a da’i.  The third and penultimate part is focused on how we can learn from the Prophet by applying his examples in the current challenges before we conclude.
Da’wah literally means a call (Oxford Islamic Studies Online, 2013), an invitation back to God, and a da’i is the person calling.  In the context of Islam, a da’i is one who extends the invitation to Islam by conveying its message of Oneness of God to others.  In the scholars’ opinion, da’wah is a responsibility of every Muslim and therefore every Muslim is a da’i.  But more than just extending the invitation to Islam, a da’i is also a leader in the sense that he is responsible for influencing the person he is doing da’wah to and impacting his life through the message.  The first da’i in the Islamic history was the Prophet Muhammad s.a.w. when Islam was unknown and faced a lot of challenges and hostility.  Today, the situation of hostility and challenges are similar.  Given God’s exhortation in the Qur’an (Asad, 1980, p 642) that in him is a good example, we should try to learn from his experience and example in applying it to our current situation.
At the advent of Islam, the Makkan society was affluent, deriving their wealth mainly from foreign trade and local bazaars and markets.  This affluence led them to indulging in vices such as gambling and drinking (Salahi, 1995, pp 48-49).  Makkah was also in the grips of idol worship even though they had interactions with the Jews in Yathrib and the Christians in other part of Arabia.  There were also a few of the hanifs in Makkah itself such as Waraqah, the cousin of Khadijah r.a. (Lings, 1983, pp 16-17, Salahi, 1995, pp 54-57) but overall, the Quraish were no longer following the faith of Abraham and changed a lot of the rituals of pilgrimage.  Besides the worship aspects, they were also very superstitious, such as using arrows for fortune telling and wearing charms for protection against the jinn.  In terms of social and moral values, they treated those who have no clan protection and especially women poorly, going to the extremes of burying alive their baby daughters (Salahi, 1995, p 51-53).
It was in this clime that the Prophet Muhammad s.a.w. was sent to call the Quraish and the rest of the world back to God through Islam.  Though born to a noble Quraish family, he grew up as an orphan and never enjoyed an affluent lifestyle.  He also had a reputation for honesty, integrity and good moral character and held the respect of the Quraish, especially after the episode of the rebuilding of the Kaabah (Lings, 1999, p 42, Salahi, 1995, pp 40-46).  This reputation is actually key to his success as a da’i.  John Adair (2010, p 65), in his assessment of the vital importance of the Prophet’s trustworthiness as a leader, mentioned “there can be no confidence without truth” and “trust, like the soul, once gone is gone forever.”  Trust is important in any relationship and the relationship between the caller (da’i) and the called hinges on that trust.  The trust the Quraish had in him was to play an important part in his da’wah work.  In his personal life, his marriage to Khadijah r.a. was a happy one, lasting till her death.  Through this marriage, he gained a firm supporter in Khadijah r.a. in his da’wah work.  His strategy as a da’i, whether it was divinely inspired or otherwise, was to focus on those closest to him first, then propagating it in private and individual basis (Al-Ghazali, 1999, p 113) until the command came to do it openly in Surah Ash-Shu’ara:214 (Asad, 1980, p574) where it was stated
“And warn [whomever thou canst reach, beginning with] thy kinsfolk.”
As a da’i, he faced many different challenges in calling to Islam and in his responses to these challenges, we can learn quite a bit.  One of the first challenges he faced was in terms the da’wah to his extended family, risking his relationship with them (al-Ghazali, 1999, p 115).  While his immediate family embraced Islam, it was not so with his extended family.  His beloved uncle, Abu Talib, gave his protection and support but would not accept the call till his death.  His uncle, Abu Lahab, turned very hostile[1]: he ridiculed the Prophet, made his sons divorce the Prophet’s daughters and abused him (Salahi, 1995, p 89, al-Ghazali, 1999, pp 116-117).  Because they were his uncles, the Prophet was put in a dilemma.  His approach in this challenge was to persevere in the da’wah efforts and to maintain the relationship even if it was rebuffed as was in the case of Abu Lahab.  His patience in enduring his uncle’s hostility without retaliation was not only proof of his gentle nature but also of his awareness of the rights of kinship. 
The next set of challenges was with the leaders of the Quraish.  Besides torturing and persecuting the small Muslim community, one of their first actions with respect to the Prophet himself was to pressure Abu Talib to make the Prophet stop his da’wah efforts or give him up to them.  These actions distressed the Prophet who thought his uncle was going to lift his protection but he still stood firm, not swayed from his cause (al-Ghazali, 1999, pp 128-129, Lings, 1983, p 52).  Next, they tried negotiating directly with him.  For example Utbah ibn Rabee’ah went to him with offers from the Quraish chiefs.  The Prophet’s actions in this instance were telling of his wisdom.  He listened attentively to the offers instead of brushing them aside.  When Utbah finished, the Prophet answered with the first 38 verses of Al-Fussilat which clearly stated the message he wanted to convey, inviting Utbah to ponder upon the signs and accept the call.  The beauty of the verses left Utbah bemused where he then counseled the Quraish chiefs to adopt a wait-and see policy even though they rejected it (al-Ghazali, 1999, pp 126-128, Salahi, 1995, pp 106-107).  Other negotiations which embodied the spirit of compromise and ‘live-and-let-live’ also failed due to the firmness and steadfastness of the Prophet in delivering his message (Salahi, 1995, pp 140-143).  They also started a smear campaign against him with the pilgrims and other visitors.  Calling him a magician and a person who sows discord between fathers and sons[2], they impressed upon the pilgrims not to listen to the Prophet and to avoid him.  The Prophet’s response was to persevere and continued to reach out to those who were willing to listen (Lings, 1983, pp 53-55, Salahi, 1995, pp 111-114).  These challenges were just some of what he and the early Muslim community faced in the da’wah effort.
From the Prophet’s example, we can identify several key characteristics that a da’i needs to develop in facing the challenges of today.  The first characteristic is that of noble character which includes trustworthiness and integrity.  It was to the point that even while they persecuted him, the Quraish still respected him and entrusted him with their belongings to the point that when the Prophet migrated, Ali r.a. was given the task to return people their belongings (Salahi, 1995, p 201).  As mentioned earlier, integrity and trustworthiness are key in engendering the trust in the da’i and by implication trust in the message.  The second and third characteristics are patience and perseverance respectively which were evident in all the challenges that the Prophet faced.  These characteristics are the key to success in any challenge in life what more in da’wah.  In the Qur’an, God says (2:153)
“O You who have attained to faith!  Seek aid in steadfast patience and prayer: for, behold, God is with those who are patient in adversity.” (Asad, 1980, p 32)
The Prophet embodied this advice from God for he was steadfastly patient and was constant in prayer which should be the model for any da’i today.  The next characteristic is wisdom and intelligence.  Wisdom in knowing your audience, knowing when to engage or otherwise and what best to say allows a da’i to be effective in his da’wah effort.  Intelligence helps the da’i in creating his da’wah strategy just like the way the Prophet strategized by focusing on those closest to him first.  This led him to build a core circle of followers who were not only his support but also in helping to propagate the message like Abu Bakr r.a.  
With these characteristics developed and armed with the knowledge and appreciation of the message, the da’i is now ready to face the challenges of today.  Like during the time of the Prophet, Islam is once again a ‘stranger’ in the global scene.  While there are countries with majority Muslims, these countries are few when compared with the rest of the world and quite a lot of Muslims live in non-Muslim countries.  As such, we see similar challenges to those faced by the Prophet and early Muslims.  For example, the challenges of doing da’wah to their non-Muslim family are being faced by many new converts to Islam.  By studying the actions of the Prophet in his relationship with and his efforts to spread the message to his immediate and extended family, the da’i is able to learn the wisdom and strategy that the Prophet applied in such situations. 
There are also a lot negative press about Islam and Muslims in the current times, similar to the smear campaign that the Quraish carried out against the Prophet and the early Muslim community.  Lessons can also be learned from the strategy the Prophet adopted to counter the smear campaign instead of acting hastily and emotionally as happened during the incident of the cartoons mocking the Prophet not so long ago.  The hostility which quite a number of Muslims faced living in a majority non-Muslim countries like in France and some parts of Australia and U.S. are again similar to the hostility confronted by the Prophet and the early Muslim community.  The Prophet’s merciful and gracious actions together with his integrity won the hearts of many of his enemies, some becoming Muslims and others became less hostile.  Today’s da’i should also set an example by his good actions which should embody the message and help soften the hearts of those around him.
It therefore behoove today’s da’i to emulate the Prophet in his characters which Aisha r.a. once described as the walking Qur’an and learn from his da’wah efforts.  There are many parallels in the challenges faced today with those faced by the Prophet that it is a shame not to use the guidance given to us by the Prophet. 
Reference:
Adair, J., 2010.  The Leadership of Muhammad.  U.K.:  Kogan Page Limited.
Al-Ghazali, M., 1999. Fiqh-Us-Seerah: Understanding the Life of Prophet Muhammad. 2nd ed. Saudi Arabia: International Islamic Publishing House.
Asad, M., 1980. The Message of the Qur’an. Gibraltar: Dar al-Andalus Limited.
Lings, M., 1983.  Muhammad: His Life Based on the Earliest Sources. U.K.: Islamic Texts Society.
Oxford Islamic Studies Online, 2013.  Da’wah. [online] Available at http://www.oxfordislamicstudies.com/article/opr/t125/e511
Salahi, M. A., 1995.  Muhammad: Man and Prophet.  U.K.:  Element Books Limited.




[1] It was to the point that Surah Al-Lahab was revealed
[2] There were other descriptions proposed such as madman and poet but was rejected by al-Walid ibn al-Mughirah because he (and the Quraish chiefs) knew that the Prophet was right and his message was beautiful  (Salahi, 1995, p 112).

Sunday 3 November 2013

When the Devil Speaks by Khaled Abou El Fadl

In the Name Of God, The Most Gracious, The Dispenser of Grace.

This entry is a copy of part of a chapter in the book 'The Search for Beauty in Islam' by Professor Khaled Abou El Fadl.  The chapter, Chapter 56 (pp190-192), is entitled 'When the Devil Speaks'.

-------------------------

When the Devil Speaks
(Khaled Abou El Fadl, The Search for Beauty in Islam, 2006)

God praises the nation that speaks without fear.  The only chosen people are those who command the good and condemn the evil (3:110).  Such is the true covenant of God, that the chosen are a people of principle, not the by-product of lineage or the inheritors of some past glory.  The covenant is a covenant of words - discharged through words.  To paraphrase the Prophet, whoever is silent before an injustice becomes as if a demon.  The beauty of God is pure goodness, and the abyss of ugliness is fear, for what other than fear can silence the soul and give the word to Satan?  God commands that we speak the truth even against those we hold most dear.  Lineage, blood, or love is not supreme - supremacy is to the word that must be spoken truthfully.

Our Exalted and Merciful God has set the unwavering word for all those who believe.  The Lord has commanded that we stand firmly for justice as witnesses for God.  If others will testify on behalf of blood or tribe, the chosen will testify only on behalf of God.  "Bear witness for God, even as against yourselves, or your parents or your kin, and whether it be against rich or poor for [whomever it may be] God has a greater entitlement over you.  Follow not the whims of your hearts, lest you swerve.  If you distort justice or fail to testify, beware that God knows all that you do." (4:135)

How can we testify if the walls of dungeons are all we can see?  How can we testify if we are not free?  How can the believers testify if they live in fear?  Are they supposed to sacrifice themselves on the alters of freedom when the altars are now in the control of demons?  What truly breaks the heart and chokes the throat is that today, the demons are humans who call themselves Muslim believers.  Yet, it does not matter what they call themselves, a name never discharged a covenant or commended anyone to the Lord.  What matters is the truth of the word, and that when the pious fall silent only the devil speaks.

I sit in the Conference, testifying to the truth of the word.  In my hand is Risalat Iblis ila Ikhwanihi al-Manahis (Satan's Epistle to His Miserable Brothers) by al-Hakim al-Jishumiyya al-Bayhaqi (d. 494/1100-1)/  The author was a Hanafi Mu'tazili jurist most of his life, and then the burdens of testimony called upon him to become a Zaydi.  He was killed and silenced in Mecca because of his book, and now he joined the Conference, and now he speaks freely.  His book, Satan's Epistle, was buried among the millions of manuscripts suppressed by the persecutors of the word until my mentor and teacher Hossein Modarresi published and liberated the work.  Al-Bayhaqi asked in his book, if Satan on the Final Day would speak, what and whom would he praise?  Satan ends up praising and thanking every Muslim who adopted a creed that attributed to God things that are irrational, unjust, or ugly.  All those who make Islam the religion of the ugly and stupid lead themselves and others astray, and Satan feels nothing but gratitude and elation for this miserable company.

I start to wonder if Satan would speak about us today, what would he say?  Which of our numerous vanities would he choose to praise?  I think Satan would have to express his profuse gratitude for our emotions, whims and fears that induce us to submit to ourselves rather than to our Lord.  Satan would be jubilant that our Lord told us to "read," and instead, we excelled in the hysteria of activism and irrationality.  In the eyes of the devil, is there a better nation than that which celebrates stupidity, and declares the use of reason to be sophistry and heresy?  Is there a better gift to depravity than a nation that treats knowledge as if it is an ornament or decoration, and not the gateway to the truth of our being?  Isn't Satan ecstatic when he finds a nation that refuses to learn from its past and constantly tries to reinvent wisdom's wheel?  Is there a greater evil than a people who testify against a knowledge they don't know, and excel at testifying on the basis of hearsay?  Isn't speaking and testifying without knowledge an act of lying and an act of deceit and perjury?  What would the devil say about a people who stuff their pulpits with despots and nominate the most ignorant to lead?  How would the devil praise a people who treat their religion as an extra-curricular activity and a "feel-good" hobby?  Isn't the devil simply elated with our esteemed sages, puerile kids who think Islam is a fashion show, and whose egos are their reference points?  They have no need for books or knowledge - they simply act the role of the wise and pious as soon as they grow the sprucely beard and find the dapper wardrobe?



Tuesday 29 October 2013

My Hajj Diary - Day 11 (end of entry)

Day 11 (18/10/2013)

Waiting for Fajr.  Alhamdulillah, Alhamdulillah, Alhamdulillah!  We have finally completed our hajj with a very smooth and beatuiful tawaf wada'.  Woken up at quarter past 12 am in the darkness by Maha.  Rini wanted to go to the Haram as soon as possible.  There were already others waiting there when we came down.

Alhamdulillah, we got a taxi almost immediately.  Got there and did the tawaf on the first floor.  Even though it was larger but we did it peacefully and tranquilly and for the first time this hajj, I actually enjoyed the tawaf.  The view of the Kaabah was still impeded but without pushing and shoving, we could really concentrate.  We then waited at Marwa for Rini while she finished her Sa'i.  Again, that went smoothly and we didn't lose each other.  We easily got a taxi back, alhamdulillah, thanks to Maha's Arabic.  So all in all, we had a smooth farewell tawaf without adventure.  A good note to end on, alhamdulillah.

Having finished all the rights of Hajj, I am just waiting till tonight to start on the leg back to London.  There is a sense of sadness and joy that my hajj journey is finally over.

The anticipation of the hajj experience building in the months before were nothing like the rush of the actual experience itself.  I will need to analyse deeper its impact on me but have I learnt anything about myself in this journey that I didn't know before?

Also I realise I have never been more grateful for my ability to read a map and visualise it in reality in order to navigate.  Alhamdulillah, now I realise what a gift it is.  Alhamdulillah, this gift has been useful in navigating my way back to Mina twice and in and around the Haram as well as in Madinah.  Ya Allah, let me always be grateful for this gift and let me use it wisely.

A weakness that was an asset for hajj is my inability to do small talks.  This allows me to block most of the chatters and concentrate on what matters.  The few discussions were on interesting matters or important matters.  What it didn't help for me is the making of friends.  But since I am not here on this journey to make friends, that is fine.  Still, alhamdulillah, to get to know a few of the sisters is a blessing.  Insha Allah, will try to stay in touch with them.


My Hajj Diary - Day 10

Day 10 (17/10/2013)

2 am - Ya Allah, please help us in this test you have given us.  I am not sure why You moved me to do the jamrat before the rest, but it made me come back in time for the return of the sister from the hospital.

11 am - We are now in the apartment again in the Aziziyah.  The challenge now is to arrange for the Tawaf Wada'.  I am disappointed that Elsawy has not arranged for the tawaf for us.  Today is, I realise, the last day of Eid.  As I said, it has been an eventful journey but the actual impact will have to be assessed later when things have sunk in.

The fact that I am not well also does not help.  The tent in Mina didn't help...it is a germ breeding ground.  I wish I had some of the ginger Sis Yusria brought.

Was talking to Mehmoona just now and she had the same disconnection to the Haram that I have been feeling.  The construction around the Kaabah is like a monstrosity.  You can't see the Kaabah anymore from the mosque.  Last year, we had an unimpeded view of the Kaabah and there was that connection, a sense of peace, yet still energetic/magnetic pull.  Now, there is nothing.  And the mostrosity of a building they are building as an extension to the mosque.  And more hotels and shopping centres are opening new the Haram.  All blitz and glitter but no substance.  Are they trying to get the people coming to Hajj and Umrah to divert their focus to shopping rather than worship?  We seem to have gone back to the Jahiliyah days when the Quraish of Mecca were using the Kaabah for commercial and status purposes. 

Thursday 24 October 2013

My Hajj Diary - Day 9

Day 9 (16/10/2013)  

Am sitting in the hot tent.  Alhamdulillah, I finished the second jamrat this morning just after fajr.  Poor Shahidah, her blisters have burst and the doctor told her that she needs to stay off her feet.  So, insha Allah, I will be doing her last jamrat for her.  Allah has been very merciful to me this hajj.  Other than a brief migraine and some sore hip, I have been relatively healthy enough to perform all the rites.  I am trying to keep up my health because there are two more acts to perform.

That was my du'a other than Shahidah's well being during the jamrat. Had been worried about her feet. Anyway, if she can't do the jamrat, I will do it for her.  And if she can't do the tawaf wada' (the farewell tawaf), she is free to go.

This morning, around breakfast time, had an interesting discussion with Sis Fyza and Yusria regarding the Qur'an, sunnah and hadith.  I am glad to hear that Fyza is thinking along similar lines.  May Allah give her strength to do what she wishes to do.  We need people who can speak up and not be afraid.

Ya Allah, today has been the strangest day.  Help the sister, Ya Allah.  She truly is needing your help.  Her condition had gotten worse since I met her several days ago at the Aziziyah. At first, she just seems enthusiastic and a bit over the top but today, she turned violent.  The sisters did well to try and keep her calm but it didn't help.  She needed professional help.

Something Shahidah said today made a lot of sense.  It links to what I said to her in the Haram yesterday.  I said this is the first time I felt like a musafir (a traveller).  Today, she said that hajj is preparing us or reminding us that we are on a journey where we tend to carry too many baggage.  It taught her to travel light.

Masya Allah, she is right.  We carry too much baggage even though we are only travellers in this world.  We need to travel light: perhaps that is one of the meaning of the ones 'who walk gently on this earth.'  That as guests of Allah on this creation of His, we shouldn't be ungrateful guests.  Two points:
1.  Too much baggage
It is more difficult to move freely.  Just look at the chaos to come to Mina with people carrying loads.  But when we went to Arafah, we were more fluid because we only carriedd really essential stuff.  I thought I carried only essentials but so many things I brought ended up not ussed.  So a lesson here is that we really get attached to things which seem essential but actually is not.  E.g. work:  since I have been here, I have not thought about work till now that is.
And remember, we all return to Him without any of things that we can really bring with us.
2.  Impact on Earth
Looking at the state of the Haram, Mina, Muzdalifah and Arafat, I am sad.  Look at the rubbish everywhere.  Bottles, tissues, peels and whatever else.  I think we used billions of bottles and it is just thrown away and not recycled.  (and not even thrown away in a responsible manner!) Where are our manners in being His guests in His House?  And cleanliness is part of Islam.  So where is it?  Caring for the earth is part of our duty as Allah's representatives.  And yet we are leaving behind millions of tonnes of rubbish which will pollute the environment.
So, we need to understand this responsibility that Allah has bestowed on us.  By truly living a life of a traveller, you realise that a traveller shouldn't leave a print of himself/herself on the place she/he is visiting.

My Hajj Diary - Day 8

Day 8 (15/10/2013 - First Day of Eid)  

It will be Fajr soon and it has been a long night.  Slept for about 3 hours before the rest came back (from Muzdalifah).  That gave me a second wind, alhamdulillah.

People are tired but we will be going for jamrat (stoning) after fajr.  May Allah make it easy for all of us.

Ya Allah, today is the day of Eid.  Just got a "message" from God (as the sister who delivered it said - which is creepy by the way!) that I need to listen more.

After Dzuhur - Alhamdulillah, finished the jamrat, tawaf ifadah and sa'i.  Am out of ihram.  Unfortunately, things are not so smooth.  We are stuck here (at the Haram) until Asr.  Dirty, tired, smelly in clothes which are three days old, I can't bring myself to actually do much du'a at all.  Too exhausted to think.

(note that the entry below is written retrospectively the day after because this day was just madness!)

Woke up at 1 am, insha Allah, an hour before we are going to do the second jamrat.  I am definitely exhausted and not feeling well.  Likely flu.  Trying to fight it.

Ya Allah, I don't know how complete my tawaf and sa'i were yesterday.  I don't really think I did much supplication, mostly dzikr.  But I had a moment; I was trying to negotiate with Allah on whether He could send me an invitation for hajj or umrah again.  At this time, I am leaning towards umrah.  Anyway, it is definitely a human trait not to be satisfied with just an invitation.

Yesterday was a tough day.  One of the most challenging in my life, I think.  First, it started with the jamrat Aqabah (the first jamrat) where we were pushed and shoved by the crowd.  The poor old lady who Shahidah had been helping in our camp was quite overwhelmed by it.  Alhamdulillah, later we found out she made it all the way to the Haram and did at least 1.5 tawaf rounds on her own two feet.

Anyway, we (Mehmoona, her family and I) got separated from the main group and tried to get back together...alhamdulillah, we managed.  The jamrat itself was fine, alhamdulillah.  Sorry, I fell asleep while writing this down.

We then walked to the Haram in a sea of people with Sis Yusria before (literally) battling the crowd during tawaf.  At one point I was swept off my feet (and if not for my hold on Shahidah I would have gone under).  There was no way to really concentrate or take pleasure in the tawaf because of the crowd.  Pushing and shoving are only 2 of the unpleasant things that occur there.  In fact it was so bad that Shahidah had a panic attack and felt faint.  Let's just say, I had a mini sa'i (like Hajar a.s.) trying to find zamzam for her.  I was worried for her because I have never seen her so overwhelmed and not in a good way.  We managed to finally settle her on the first floor at Safa while waiting for her to recover.  Started our sa'i after dzuhur and finished by 2 pm but we weren't able to find Sis Yusria and so we stayed until Asr before giving up.

Alhamdulillah that we did because we would have missed the bus to take us to Mina from the apartments in Aziziyah.  (I would suggest that no one ever stays at the Aziziyah during Hajj - it is a nightmare to find a taxi to go there and we paid SAR100 each for the trip) But the trip from Aziziyah to Mina was another adventure in itself.  The bus dropped us at the start of Mina.  We had to walk a distance before having to cross the highway with cars/buses travelling 70 miles/hr or more.  I lost my cool a little (probably a lot) at that time because the brothers didn't know/weren't sure the way to the camp and they weren't consulting the map.  Alhamdulillah for the maps all over Mina.  Managed to work out where we needed to go and I just proceeded on.  (I left the brothers to their wrangling and walked on.)  Not a team player certainly and I still need to work on my patience.  Ya Allah, truly this Hajj is a test on my patience.

Came back to camp and found Sis Yusria already back.  Alhamdulillah, I was worried that she waited for us and we left her.  Alhamdulillah, Alhamdulillah, Alhamdulillah, truly it was the most challenging day but I managed to achieve what I set out to do and I am no longer in ihram.

My Hajj Diary - Day 7

Day 7 (14/10/2013 - 9th Dzulhijjah) - Day of Arafah 

I wish we could have left Mina after Fajr as per the Sunnah of the Prophet but I understand the logistics is such that it wasn't going to happen.  But alhamdulillah, we are here in Arafah, waiting for Fajr.  From my spot, I can see the stars and just now, it is cool enough to be outside where I can see Orion's Belt.  Masha Allah!

I am overwhelmed by the feeling of gratefulness to be here.  To be given the chance to be truly part of Hajj.  Ya Allah, let me always be among the grateful.  Ya Allah, let me have patience over hajj.  I have resolved to walk to Muzdalifah and Mina tonight.  It will be a long and dusty walk but insha Allah, I will endure.  Keep me safe through this journey, Ya Allah.

Oh, I forgot a thought I had on the way here:  I have not been on the internet for over a week.  And I rediscovered the beauty of the pen and paper again.

It is not even 10 am and it is already very hot.  Masha Allah, if we can't stand this heat in the shade, what about the time when we are on the Day of Judgement?  When there is no shade except those on whom Allah has mercy.

Prophet Ibrahim a.s. supplication in 26:83-85
ربِّ هب لِّى حُكما و الحِقْنى بالصلحين واجعل لى لسان صدْقٍ في الآخرين و اجعلنى من ورثهِ جنَّة النعيم
O my sustainer, endow me with the ability to judge (between right and wrong) and make me one of the righteous and grant me power to convey the truth unto those who will come after me and place me among those who shall inherit the garden of bliss!

I was thinking about the heat and I wonder about those living on the streets, how they take to the heat and others to the cold.  This makes me resolve to go for the challenge to sleep rough.  Yet both conditions are temporary for me, Masha Allah!  How can I not be grateful for the gifts He has given me!  Ya Allah, let me be among the grateful.

Nearly 12 pm and I have resorted to leaving the tent and sitting in the blazing sun outside.  The difficulty is the noises drowning out the voice within.  This is alluding to our daily lives too where so many noise vie for our attention without giving us time for ourselves.  Today, the day of Arafah, I had hoped for quiet time to reflect but that is my test, I believe.  Alhamdulillah for this walkway for it is helping me get away.  Ya Allah, how do I get away in real life?  When do I take time to get away from thoughts of life to reflect on myself, my relationship with you and the rest of your creation?  Help me, Ya Allah, help me.

Alhamdulillah, after dzuhur, and I am sitting outside under the shade of a tree, pilgrims all around me and birds chirping from the branches.  A sister's husband brought me some zamzam water (May Allah reward them for their kindness.)  Ya Allah, I saw much kindness around me this hajj which gives me hope for the Ummah.  If only we can harness this kindness to change the world.

On the one hand, I wish this day would never end and on the other, I am looking forward to the other acts of hajj.  Ya Allah, let me get another invitation to Your house!

The last hour before leaving Arafah.  I posed the question of how we can change ourselves and the Ummah for we know that Allah does not change a person/community unless they change themselves.  What are the necessary actions?

After 9 pm, alhamdulillah at Muzdalifah after walking for almost 3 hours.  Masha Allah, it was worth it to walk even though now I have to ask some Indonesians if I could keep their company for some time.  Not sure if I will stay for Fajr as I am not sure when they (my group) will leave for jamrah.  There is still a ways to go to my camp in Mina.

Anyway, back to the walk - the energy is electrifying.  You could feel what was described in the Qur'an regarding people pouring down from Arafah.  Felt like you are swept away by a sea of people.  But Masha Allah, there were pockets of free space that I didn't feel claustrophobic at all. Allah protected me along the way and provided for me.  There were water coolers when I needed them and also bought an apple and some grapes for food.

People are still streaming in, I can see them walking past me.  There are people everywhere I look and shops line the streets.  Also hawkers.  I left the Indonesians as I didn't feel comfortable imposing on them.  Been walking and now have stopped at the border of Muzdalifah and Mina.  At the African Section (Section 5).  Hawkers line the street and I even saw two women cooking something in a big pot.  Probably to sell tomorrow morning.  Found out the Indonesians didn't belong to a camp but sleeping in the street.  Not all in Muzdalifah are as lucky, I notice, as I am.  Life is very different on the streets than in the 'rarified' world of the middle classes.

Alhamdulillah that I made a decision to walk.  You find out the colourful nature of the world.




Wednesday 23 October 2013

My Hajj Diary - Day 6

Day 6 (13/10/2013 and also 8th Dzulhijjah) - Day/Night to spend in Mina.

Alhamdulillah, we arrived safely in Mina.  Had some sleep and prayed fajr.  Things are a bit chaotic but alhamdulillah, I have been trying to follow Sumayia's advice to sit/lay down and do my own dzikr.  What do I feel?  Not sure except that I am trying to do what is needed.  Ya Allah, let me be amongst those who are grateful and successful.

Being in a tent with 58 other people is a challenge in itself.  So many distractions and also the need to compromise.  Perhaps that is the lesson to be learnt in Mina.  There is wisdom in enduring the idiosyncrasies of everyone and learning more about oneself as a consequence.

Was reading Surah Al-Furqan: 61-76:  descriptions of the servants of Ar-Rahman (The Most Gracious), those who are grateful:
1.  Walk gently on the earth
2.  Words of peace for the foolish
3.  Remember their Sustainer far into the night
4.  Pray to avert Hell.
5.  Spend on others in a balanced way - neither too much nor too little
6.  Not do the following - set up anything/anyone beside God, kill unjustly, commit adultery
7.  Repent if they did the above, attain to faith and do a good deed (in replacement)
8.  Never bear witness to falsehood
9.  Not engaged in frivolity
10.  Try to understand God's words with deeper/conscious effort
11.  Pray to be conscious of Him and that their family be a source of comfort.


Questions:
1.  What does it mean to 'walk gently on the earth'?
          - not spread corruption on earth
          - minimise impact on the environment (learn from the Native Americans and other Oborigins)
          - spread good
          - what else?

2.  Words of peace for the foolish?
         - do not engage them in hate or anger
         - speak nicely to them

3.  Why the three sins?  Are they the most major or is there something about these acts which have further implications?  What is the significance of doubling the punishment in the hereafter for these?

4.  What about family life?  How is the family as a source of comfort lead to consciousness of God?


As to character of the Prophet which we should strive to emulate:
- sweet disposition, noble character, deep thought, sound reasoning and trustworthy attitude.

Just heard the news of Pak Lang Sarip's death before dzuhur prayer.  That is a shock to the system.  Will need to check with Dad when I return.  May Allah have mercy on his soul.  He was very kind to my late mother and to me.

Finished the maghrib prayer.  The talk/lecture after prayers is on niyah (intention).  Ya Allah, purify my intention: to do this for You alone.

Alhamdulillah, it is always lovely to see the enthusiasm of the young.  A sister was inspired by the poor pilgrims on the street that she is collecting all the uneaten food to be distributed on the street.  May Allah reward her for her effort.

Tuesday 22 October 2013

My Hajj Diary - Day 5

و هو الذى أرسل الرِّيٰح بُشْرا بين يدىْ رحمته
وأنزلنا من السماء ماء طهورا
لنحىِ به بلدة مَّيتا و نسقيه ممّا خلقنا أنعاما و أنا سىَّ كثيرا.
And He it is who sends forth the winds as a glad tiding of His Coming Grace and (thus too) We cause pure water to descend from the skies so that We may bring dead land to life thereby, and give to drink thereof to many (beings) of Our Creations, beasts as well as humans
(Al-Furqan:48-49)

Today is the day of rest before we head out to Mina tonight, insha Allah.  I was just reading the above passage and thinking how appropriate these verses are in the context of the land we are in.  The barren desert with rocks and mountains truly need the life giving rain water.  We (I) don't truly appreciate it, living in Scotland.

And a remark by Shahidah a few days ago about the cool wind also comes to mind.  In this area, the cool wind is a sign of His blessings and Grace.  May He make this journey easy for us and grant us cool winds along the way.  Ameen.

Maghrib has arrived and I have done my ghusl.  Prayed qasr and jama'.  Been trying to be quiet and focus.  I guess I am not good at dzikr or reading the Qur'an consistently but I am trying.  I am also reading the books I brought with me so that I can catch up on my readings and reflect.  Perhaps that is the best I can do.  Ya Allah, accept this hajj of mine.

There seems to be some confusion as to the salah for Ihram.  Two questions that might help clarify matters:-
1.  When the Prophet s.a.w. prayed two raka'ah at Bir-Ali (or other miqat), did there exist a mosque there already?  Was his intention that of salah al-Masjid or for Ihram?

2.  What did the Companions do after they came out of ihram and then went back into it when they did hajj tamattu' on the first and final hajj of the Prophet s.a.w.?

These questions should highlight if there is a salah specially for ihram.  Will need to read up more on the hadiths and athars related to them.

My Hajj Diary - Day 4

Day 4 (11/10/2013)

9am - Alhamdulillah, arrived safely at 3 am in the morning at the apartments in Aziziyah.  It was a long journey...we set off from Madinah at 3 pm and then from Bir-Ali at almost 7 pm before reaching Mecca close to 2 am.  Drove around for about an hour before arriving at our destination.

So haven't really slept because by the time we settled down, it was time for fajr and we (Shahidah and I) decided to perform our umrah.  Alhamdulillah, we finished it well before 9 am and am now having a well deserved breakfast.  Sitting here at the food court, I miss my family.  Last year, they were here with me.

3 pm - Back at the apartment after Juma'ah.  It was difficult to find a taxi but alhamdulillah, Shahidah managed to get one for us.  Rested a little but still tired.  Will rest for the rest of today and tomorrow as the focus should be on hajj.

Today, doing the umrah, I was in a daze.  It was probably the tiredness but the sight of the Ka'abah didn't move me as much as usual.  Also, didn't know what to pray for.  Mind was a blank.  But still alhamdulillah, my umrah is completed.

Ya Allah, let me be able to walk safely alone if no one else wishes to go with me.

My Hajj Diary - Day 2

YDay 2 (09/10/2013)

Waiting for Asr in Masjid Nabawi.  It has been an emotional day.  Had a good rest last night, alhamdulillah.  But while waiting for Dzuhur, I was thinking of the book on the puritans vs the moderates.  (The Great Theft: Wrestling Islam from the Extremist by Khaled Abou El Fadl which I was reading to Shahidah on the plane here)  I realised how daunting the challenges that the Ummah faces but two things stood out:
1.  God does not burden us more than we can bear.
2.  God does not change a people unless we change ourselves.

Thus this is my du'a:
1.  That I am able to make some small contributions towards the change that we need to make.
2.  That I not be overwhelmed and daunted by the task.

My resolve:
1.  Gain an understanding of the religion through learning and scholarship
2.  Contribute to the body of knowledge
3.  Spread good in this world through the various good works and stand for justice wherever it may be.

I was reading Surah An-Nur: 57-60 and the following questions come to mind:
1.  What is the wisdom behind these verses in regulating the privacy of a person?
2.  When and in what circumstances is it applicable?
3.  What is the meaning ثِيابَهنَّ (outer garments) in this verse?  How is it related to modesty and how old is that - related to sexual desire or marriage?

After Isha' prayers:  "Ilm is Islam" stated Rosenthal in his book and yet as I walk around Madinah I wonder where are the bookshops?  When I first came here (over a decade ago), I remember seeing rows of bookshops and similarly when I went with my dad and Cik Nani.  But these two days, I only spotted a single big bookshop and a scattering of tiny ones with nothing really substantial.  Instead I see hotels being built, tourist type shops taking over and spreading everywhere.  Everything except the very thing this Ummah needs - 'ilm.

'Ilm has been the characteristic of this Ummah since the very beginning and yet today, this is absent.  Where are our Ibn Khaldun, Ibn Haytham, Ibn Al-'Aarbi, Al-Ghazali etc.?  Ignorance is spreading.  Our young are no longer rooted in the Islamic scholarship and history.  Our women are illiterate when before they were amongst our top scholars and teachers of our top scholars.  It is very important for us to pursue and revive this culture of knowledge and it should start with the self.

Questions that I have:
1.  Who is responsible to preserving and granting/withholding access to the old manuscripts of past Islamic scholars?
2.  Why are some materials not accessible?

10 pm - Went to the bookshop.  The books for English readers were the same as can be found elsewhere and perhaps more limited.  Very disappointing.

My Hajj Diary - Day 1

In the Name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Dispenser of Grace.

Alhamdulillah, I was invited this year to be His guest for Hajj this year.  Some people are invited many times over while others struggle to get invited.  So, alhamdulillah for the invitation and no one can predict the future, however, there is something in me that tells me that this is to be my first and last hajj.  May Allah accept it.

Thus, on this brilliant,demanding and at times scary journey, I have written an ongoing diary of my observations, thoughts etc.  I hope by sharing some of the entries of the diary, others can benefit from my experiences.

Wassalam,
Sid

------------------------------------
Day 1 (8/10/2013)
5.30 am - Alhamdulillah!  Alhamdulillah!  We have arrived safely in the beloved city of the Prophet s.a.w.  Miracles do happen - Shahidah is absolutely fine after 5.5 hours of flight.  Insha Allah, we are on the bus, waiting to be taken to our hotel.  Alhamdulillah! Alhamdulillah!  I hope that the rest of the journey will be as smooth.  May Allah grant me patience throughout this journey.  Right now, I am looking forward to be in the company of the Prophet and the Companions in the blessed city.  Alhamdulillah for His call.  Labbaik!

8.43 am - Finally arrived at the hotel after a long delay at the airport parking lot.  Now we have to wait till 12 pm to check in.

2.30 pm - Went to Masjid Nabawi for Dzuhur.

4.00 pm - Right now, sitting in the Masjid after Asr.  Alhamdulillah finally showered and changed clothes.  What a ni'mah, that is.  What is more a ni'mah is to be able to sit here in the relative calmness of the Prophet's mosque.  Sent my salam to the Prophet earlier.  I pray that God will let me be amongst His grateful servants like the Prophet s.a.w. and his companions.  Let me never be ungrateful for His favours upon me.


I was reading the following verse in the Quran:
و إذا دُعُوا إلى الله ورسولهِ لِيَحْكُمَ بينهم إذا فَريق مِنهم معرضون

(When they are called to/summoned unto God and His Apostle that he/it might judge between them, lo! a party of them turn away)

And I had two different translations in my kindle for the term ليحْكم.  In one translation, it said "he might judge", i.e. that the Prophet, and in another translation, "it [the divine writ] might judge".  The ability to interprete  ليحْكم into the two different interpretation gives rise into a rich meaning of the term -

1.  Who judges?
2.  If the Prophet s.a.w., how does he continue to judge even after his death?  In what sense?
3.  If it is the Qur'an (divine writ), how does it act as a judge?
4.  What implications do the different interpretation have upon us?

And yet there are other words with precise meaning in the Qur'an for which if you substitute a different word, the meaning changes.  What a beautiful book, Masha Allah.

Summary:  All in all, alhamdulillah, a good day if a bit tiring.  Been able to pray all the 4 prayers in Masjid Al-Nabawi.  Soaking in the peace and marveling at the diversity of Muslims.




Sunday 20 October 2013

Survival tips for those who want to embark on Hajj

In the Name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Dispenser of Grace

Alhamdulillah I have just returned from one of the most momentous journeys in my life.  I don't normally say that given that I consider myself to be a relatively well travelled person.  But tha hajj is a different kettle of fish altogether.  Each person's hajj is different and individual but there are several things that will be similar and we can learn from those experiences, insha Allah.

So the following are my advice to those contemplating hajj while you are still relatively young and fit:

1.  Prepare your list of du'a/supplications because hajj is all about supplication.  

You don't do much prayer as you are considered a traveller.  But the Quran and supplications are your two main tools to communicate with your Creator.  A supplication is best from the heart and repeated often.  I see people with du'a books but I think it isn't necessary because the best du'a should be tailored to individual needs.  And God knows all languages...a sincere du'a is, to my mind, more likely to be accepted than one that is parroted.

2.  You are a traveller, so travel light.  
All you need is two pairs of ihram (for men) or comfortable loose clothes (for women) on hajj and another one kept aside for the way home.  A small kit of toiletry is more than enough.  I survived on a small toothbrush, small tube of toothpaste, and soap.  If you want to pack a small comb, that's a luxury.  Believe me, you don't need anything more than that in Mina and less in Arafah.  And don't buy gifts...truly there is nothing there that you can't find elsewhere.  The best gift is your du'a for those people you love and care for.

A lesson I learnt on this journey is the less baggage you have the easier your journey will be.  The same should be applied in our journey in this life.

3.  Get fit by walking
Before you embark on hajj, start training your body and feet by walking long walks.  Try walking 5 miles everyday if possible.  Insha Allah, You will find that you won't get much blisters nor will you find yourself too exhausted when you do that.

The reason why I am giving this advice is that I am advising people to do lots of walking during hajj.  Walk from Arafah to Muzdalifah and then from Muzdalifah to Mina. From Mina to the jamraat and onwards to the Haram.  This way, you will see the exact condition of the Ummah and not your own micro community/group.  You will learn how the poor amongst us survive and live while we are comfortably settled in our relatively cool tents.  You will witness the tonnes of rubbish we all produce and strewn all over the place.  And perhaps then awareness will start blooming in the hearts that this Ummah needs to change and change fast because we are in critical condition.

4.  Useful things to bring.
A sister I met in my group has been to hajj 9 times and there was one thing she always bring with her - ginger powder.  A pinch of ginger with honey in your tea or coffee will help keep up your immune system, insha Allah.  Alhamdulillah, with the ginger, I was able to stave off the flu till the day I finished the tawaf wada'.

Lozenges and paracetamol are quite useful too.  

Another useful thing is a tea towel.  It is smaller than a small towel and larger than a face towel.  So you can soak it with cold water and put it over your head in the heat.  That will help cool you down.

Draw string waterproof bag for shower in Mina.  Your things will get wet because the cubicle is very small and you don't want things to fall into the toilet hole below.  

5. Food for your survival
If you are vegetarian, your food choice is very limited and if you are not, you will get tired of rice and chicken.

So some good food tips, go out of the camps to the road side stalls.  They have some fresh fruits and perhaps veg like cucumber and tomatoes.  Also they probably have some veg curry.  For those practising macrobiotic diet, forget about it.  Not the place for it.

The best thing is to drink plenty of Zamzam and water.  I didn't touch any soft drinks at all but that is my preference.

6. Patience and socialising
There will be delays, chaos and people's personality that will test the patient of a saint.  But just keep reminding yourself that this hajj is a test on patience and supplicate that God grant you patience.  

Try not to socialise too much.  Keep your own company most of the time.  One of the best advice a friend gave me was to block out all chit chat, lay down the mattress and start with dzikr and du'a as soon as you get to Mina.  You need to get yourself into an introspective frame of mind for Arafah.  

May Allah accept all our Hajj!

Sunday 22 September 2013

Hajj

In the Name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Dispenser of Grace

Last year, I had planned to go to Hajj but Allah had not called me for it. Insha Allah, He will call me this year instead. Hajj is a once in a lifetime event for a Muslim though there are many who have gone more than once. As I am preparing myself for Hajj, I think back to the time of the Prophet s.a.w. and the joys and frustrations the early Muslims had to endure for their umrah and hajj.

Insha Allah, I will be walking the same route and performing the same rituals as the Prophet s.a.w and his companions.  May Allah accept my Hajj.  I hope to write the next Seerah post on Hajj when I return.

Monday 5 August 2013

On the joys of Contemplation of Nature, Reading and Silence (during Ramadhan 2013)

In the Name of God, the Most Gracious, the Dispenser of Grace.

This Ramadhan has passed by so fast...tonight will be the 28th night and soon Ramadhan will be over.  Each Ramadhan takes on a different hue and tone.  It is the same and yet different.  I guess it is like Doctor Who in a sense...the same 'person' but with different characteristics.  And I am its companion on this journey...like any companion of Doctor Who, I have been transformed by its visitation every time.

This time, it is no different.  Last Ramadhan inculcated a sense of gratefulness into me.  This Ramadhan has brought me something different...a sense of purpose and resolve.  I reconnected with the Qur'an and rediscovered the joy of reading.  In the first half, it was the book entitled 'Imam Shatibi's Theory of the Higher Objectives of Islamic Law" that became my constant companion other than the Qur'an.  From it, I learnt the need to understand the underlying purpose of the Shari'ah and to evaluate Islamic Law based on these higher objectives.  The law no longer feels like a mechanical imposition...its beauty and complexity is starting to shine through.  The second half is filled with several books as my companions, one of them that I finished in a few hours is a little gem by Jonas Slaats (his page:  http://www.jonasyunus.net/) entitled 'Ego-removal: The way of prophets and sages.'  It touched on the various religious traditions and the common theme of divesting oneself of one's ego to either reconnect with God or to attain nothingness (in Buddhism). There are a few more books calling to me to finish them...but all in all, my readings have taken me to a resolution that I need to master Arabic and get on a learning program.  So, I have signed up for an advance diploma (bridge to a Masters) in Islamic Studies.

The plan for these last ten days of Ramadhan was to go into i'tiqaf and I had booked my leave from last Friday to Thursday.  Unfortunately, God had other plans and I was not able to fulfill my plan for i'tiqaf.  I pondered and asked Him to give me knowledge of the wisdom behind that.  Let's just say, the weather since Friday has been lovely, even if today it is overcast and with slight drizzle.  Definitely not a weather to be cooped up indoors.  So, away I went heading five minutes up the road to Blackford Hill the last four days, spending 3 to 4 hours by myself in contemplation of nature.  Sitting the first two days amidst the tall grass, I found shelter from the winds along with numerous others - bees and insects and mice...I even got scolded by a field mouse for co-opting its place for my hideout.

My silence only highlighted the rhythmic sounds of nature...the rustling of the grass and leaves, the chirping of the birds, the buzz of the bees and flies, the chittering of the mice.  There is such peace and tranquility amidst all that sound...everything in its place and time.  God has created everything in perfect harmony and with purpose even if it is not orderly.  Under the movement of the clouds and their formation, showered by the droplet of life-giving rain, in the warmth of the sun, I sat and wondered at my own purpose.  I was the anomaly in the landscape...where do I fit into the picture, into the world of nature, in this cycle of life?

My retreat is not yet complete.  Two more days to go...in my silent contemplation of nature hopefully is the remembrance of God and 'in the remembrance of God do hearts find peace.'

God knows best.



PS.  Some photos I took during my wandering on Blackford Hill.








Tuesday 30 July 2013

The development of God's message in Surah Hud - addendum

In the Name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Dispenser of Grace.

After all the stories of the prophets a.s. and their people...communities in which God destroyed, God had something else to add to His message:

(116-119)  But, alas, among those generations [whom We destroyed] before your time there were no people endowed with any virtue - [people] who would speak out against [the spread of] corruption on earth - except the few of them whom We saved [because of their righteousness], whereas those who were bent on evildoing only pursued pleasures which corrupted their whole being, and so lost themselves in sinning.

For never would thy Sustainer destroy a community for wrong [beliefs alone] so long as its people behave righteously [towards one another].  And had thy Sustainer so willed, He could surely have mankind one single community: but [He willed it otherwise, and so] they continue to hold divergent views - [all of them,] save those upon whom thy Sustainer has bestowed His grace.

And to this end has He created them[all].

But [as for those who refuse to avail themselves of divine guidance,] that word of thy Sustainer shall be fulfilled: "Most certainly will I fill hell with invisible beings as well as humans, all together!"

Here, the 'moral of the story' is revealed:
- these communities were not destroyed due to their holding to wrong beliefs but due to their appalling behaviour towards God's creatures.  In Note 149 of Chapter 11...
...Explaining the above verse in this sense, Razi says: "God chastisement does not afflict any people merely on account of their holding beliefs amounting to shirk and kufr, but afflicts them only if they persistently commit evil in their mutual dealings, and deliberately hurt [other human beings] and act tyranically [towards them].  Hence, those who are learned in Islamic Law (al-fuqaha) hold that men's obligations towards God rest on the principle of [His] forgiveness and liberality, whereas the rights of man are of a stringent nature and must always be strictly observed" - the obvious reason being that God is almighty and needs no defender, whereas man is weak and needs protection.
- that diversity in our thoughts, beliefs etc are a part of God's plan that makes us moral creatures with relative free will.  This freedom of choice (free will) is God's gift to us.  In Note 150 of Chapter 11...
Thus, the Quran stresses once again that the unceasing differentiation in men's views and ideas is not incidental but represents a God-willed, basic factor of human existence.  If God had willed that all human beings should be of one persuasion, all intellectual progress would have been ruled out, and "they would have been similar in their social life to the bees and the ants, while in their spiritual life they would have been like the angels, constrained by their nature always to believe in what is true and always to obey God" (Manar XII, 193) - that is to say, devoid of that relative free will which enables man to choose between right and wrong and this endows his life - in distinction from all other sentient beings - with a moral meaning and a unique spiritual potential.
 And in Note 152...
According to Zamakhshari, it refers to the freedom of moral choice which characterises man and is spoken of in the preceding passages: and since it is this freedom which constitutes God's special gift to man and raises him above all other created beings (c.f. the parable of Adam and the angels in 2:30-34), Zamakshari's interpretation is, in my opinion, the most comprehensive of all.
- therefore, the message is there for guidance to those who choose to be guided.  

God knows best.


The development of God's Message in Surah Hud (Chapter 11 of the Qur'an) Part 2

In the Name Of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Dispenser of Grace.

Earlier the stories of Noah, Hud and Salih a.s. showed how the central core message remains the same - the worship of God alone - while the concept of who God is and the social aspects of the message is being developed slowly through each subsequent 'story'.  Truly, a most beautiful story ever told.  In this next section, we are introduced to a few new 'players'.

The Story of Abraham a.s. and his wife

(69-70)  And, indeed, there came unto Abraham Our [heavenly] messengers, bearing a glad tiding.  They bade him peace; [and] he answered, "[And upon you be] peace!" - and made haste to place before them a roasted calf.  But when he saw that their hands did not reach out towards it, he deemed their conduct strange and became apprehensive of them.  [But] they said: "Fear not!  Behold, we are sent to the people of Lot."

(71-72)  And his wife, standing [nearby], laughed [with happiness]; whereupon We gave her the glad tiding of [the birth of] Isaac and, after Isaac, of [his son] Jacob.  Said she: "Oh, woe is me!  Shall I bear a child, now that I am an old woman and this husband of mine is an old man?  Verily, that would be strange thing indeed!"

(73)  Answered [the messengers]: "Dost thou deem it strange that God should decree what He wills?  The grace of God and His blessings be upon you, O people of this house!  Verily, ever to be praised, sublime is He!"

When I read this 'story' of the announcement of the birth of Isaac a.s., I asked myself how this fits into the evolving story of the message.  The contrast here are as follows:
1.  The messengers here are angels rather than human.
2.  They bring glad tidings rather than warnings.
3.  For the first time, a woman is introduced in this Surah.

My thoughts on how this fits into the development of the Message is:
- It is significant that Sarah, the wife of Abraham a.s., was the one directly given the glad tiding and conversed with the angels.  It showed that the message is inclusive of all - the weak, the strays (animals), the women etc.
- the concept of God being able to intervene in the natural process/laws that He has ordained in this world.  The concept that "When God wills a thing to be, He but says unto it, 'Be' and it is."
- the contrast between this 'scene' and the forthcoming 'scene' of a loving husband wife relationship as compared to the aggression/abominations of the people of Sodom.  
             
Note: I was reading earlier this month about the higher objectives of Islamic Law and one of its 'essential' objectives is the protection of the progeny.  Therefore, there is an emphasis on marriage and proper conduct in marriage to protect the progeny.  

The Story of Lot a.s.

(77)  And when Our messengers came unto Lot, he was sorely grieved on their account, seeing that it was beyond his power to shield them; and he exclaimed: "This is a woeful day!"

(78)  And his people came running to him, impelled towards his house [by their desire]: for they had ever been wont to commit [such] abominations.

Said [Lot]: "O my people! [Take instead] these daughters of mine: they are purer for you [than men]!  Be, then, conscious of God, and disgrace me not by [assaulting] my guests.  Is there not among you even one right-minded man?"

(79)  They answered: "Thou hast always known that we have no use whatever for thy daughters; and, verily, well dost thou know what we want!"

(80)  Exclaimed [Lot]: "Would that I had the strength to defeat you, or that I could lean upon some mightier support!"

(81)  [Whereupon the angels] said: "O Lot!  Behold, we are messengers from thy Sustainer!  Never shall [thy enemies] attain to thee!  Depart, then, with thy household while it is yet night, and let none of you look back...

For this story, I will side step the issue of homosexuality till the end of this blog.  It is an issue that I have been grappling with for many years since I met and knew friends and acquaintances who are homosexuals.  For now, let us look at the text and how the message evolved...

Again, like the story of Abraham a.s. and his wife, the story of Lot does not fit into the 'formulaic' story telling of the previous prophets nor of that of Shu'ayb a.s. which is coming.  Here are a people lost to their desires that they would commit such an abominable act - that of sexual assault and rape!  They were demanding Lot to turn his innocent visitors over to them to gratify their base desires.  The contrast of such base desires to the loving relationship of Abraham and his wife, sharing in the glad tidings of their progeny, is quite stark.  

So, I ask myself if there is a link to how God's  message evolves and these are my thoughts:
- God's is the mightiest of support as in Note 111 of Chapter 11 that said '...for the Prophet Muhammad, referring to this Qur'anic passage, is reported to have said, "God bestowed His grace upon Lot, for he betook himself indeed unto a mighty support!" '
- the idea of restraining from one's desires through the consciousness of God; that was the appeal of Lot to his people.


The Story of Shu'ayb a.s.

(84-86)  And unto [the people of] Madyan [We sent] their brother Shu'ayb.  He said: "O my people! Worship God [alone]: you have no deity other than Him; and do not give short measure and weight [in any of your dealings with men].  Behold, I see you [now] in a happy state; but, verily, I dread lest suffering befall you on a Day that will encompass [you with doom]!  Hence, O my people, [always] give full measure and weight, with equity, and do not deprive people of what is rightfully theirs, and do not act wickedly on earth by spreading corruption.  That which rests with God is best for you, if you but believe [in Him]!  However, I am not your keeper."

(87)  Said they: "O Shu'ayb!  Does thy [habit of] praying compel thee to demand of us that we give up all our forefathers were wont to worship, or that we refrain from doing what we please with our possessions?  Behold, [thou wouldst have us believe that] thou art indeed the only clement, the only right-minded man!"

(88-90)  He answered: "O my people!  What do you think?  If [it be true that] I am taking my stand on a clear evidence from my Sustainer, who has vouchsafed me goodly sustenance [as a gift] from Himself - [how could I speak to you otherwise than I do]?  And yet, I have no desire to do, out of opposition to you, what I am asking you not to do.  I desire no more than to set things to rights in so far as it lies within my power; but the achievement of my aim depends on God alone.  In Him have I placed my trust, and unto Him do I always turn!  And O my people, let not [your] dissent from me drive you into sin, lest there befall you the like of what befell the people of Noah, or the people of Hud, or the people of Salih: and [remember that] the people of Lot lived not very far from you!  Hence, ask your Sustainer to forgive you your sins, and then turn towards Him in repentance - for, verily, my Sustainer is a dispenser of grace, a fount of love!"

(91)  [But his people] said: "O Shu'ayb!  We cannot grasp the purport of much of what thou sayest; on the other hand, behold, we do see clearly how weak thou art in our midst: and were it not for thy family, we would have most certainly  stoned thee to death, considering that thou hast no power over us!"

(92-93)  Said he: "O my people!  Do you hold my family in greater esteem than God? - for, Him you regard as something that may be cast behind you and be forgotten!  Verily, my Sustainer encompasses [with His might] all that you do!  Hence, O my people, do [to me] anything that may be within your power, [while] I, behold, shall labour [in God's way]; in time you will come to know which [of us] shall be visited by suffering that will cover him with ignominy, and which [of us] is a liar.  Watch, then, [for what is coming] behold, I shall watch with you!"

Here the development of the message goes another step:
- justice and equity in dealing with others goes hand in hand with the belief in God [alone].
- admonishment not to spread corruption
- sustenance is a gift from God and therefore, not one's possession per say to do as one wish
- admonishment not to follow one's ancestors blindly
- trust in God
- should learn from history for in history are signposts for those who think.


These are just some insights I gleaned in my reading of the Surah.  Allah knows best if I am correct.




----------------------------------------

On Homosexuality:


My first encounter with homosexuality is, typically, in books.  But then, I met a friend of a friend who was a homosexual.  He was a sweet man.  Since then, I have met and known several others who are just as kind and lovely.  It therefore troubled me regarding the stand of the various religions, particularly in my own religion, against homosexuality.  It also troubled me when I find around me people who are homophobic.  To my mind, there is little engagement within the Muslim community regarding this issue...we seem to prefer burying our heads in the sand than to acknowledge that there is an issue to be resolved.

It is quite a coincidence that while I am grappling to put down my thoughts in this blog, I read a statement by Pope Francis regarding homosexuals.  Let me quote them here:

Speaking to reporters on a flight back from Brazil, he reaffirmed the Roman Catholic Church's position that homosexual acts were sinful, but homosexual orientation was not.

"If a person is gay and seeks God and has good will, who am I to judge them?"

"The Catechism of the Catholic Church explains this very well," Pope Francis said in a wide-ranging 80-minute long interview with Vatican journalists.
"It says they should not be marginalised because of this but that they must be integrated into society."

Many years ago, I attended a talk in Darul Arqam in Singapore and the speaker said something similar - that there must be a separation between the act and the person.  Based on my memory, he said that the person should not be ostracised but should be befriended and guided while in Islam, it is the act that is forbidden.

While we don't want to acknowledge it, but homosexuality and transgender issues have been there since time immemorial.  It is interesting to note that Muslim scholars in the past have tackled the issue as this paper suggested.  More than that, this paper discusses the nurture vs nature arguments put for in terms of homosexuality.
http://www.lamppostproductions.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/Islam-Homosexuality1.pdf


These are other writings from the Islamic perspective.

http://mohamedghilan.com/2013/05/06/religion-homosexuality-same-sex-marriage/

http://www.tariqramadan.com/spip.php?article10683&lang=fr

http://www.suhaibwebb.com/islam-studies/homosexual-wanting-to-embrace-islam-advice-from-ust-suhaib-webb/

I am still grappling with the issue...but for me, one thing is clear.  People, whether they are hetero- or homo-sexuals, women or men, disabled or otherwise, which ever religion or race, should be given equal rights in society - that of the basic human rights and should be treated with respect and compassion.

I will end with a quote from the first paper I cited above:

That being so, as a Muslim who has and will continue to encounter other Muslims
struggling with homosexual thoughts and urges, it is important for the Muslim
community to approach this topic with much more empathy and less prejudgment. Our
children are now growing up in a culture where homosexual encounters and public
discourse about gay acceptance is more normative. Though we try our best to insulate
them from what we deem to be corruptive forces, there is no doubt that we won’t be
able to protect them all the time. For that reason, it is important for us to understand
homosexual psychology and the theories surrounding its genesis. It is also important to
know this information, because many of us are expected to pastor to very diverse
populations. Imams, scholars, and jurists alike have and will continue to be visited by
Muslims who seek to become whole and/or to at least figure out ways to understand
their predicament. Just as harshness with alcoholics and drug addicts can alienate and
send them deeper into their addiction, it is important that those who know we have the
capacity for an uncustomary amount of compassion to be available for our brethren,
listen with an empathetic ear, and guard their secrets so they are able to achieve a
sense of fulfillment and fullness in their lives.


Sunday 28 July 2013

The development of God's Message in Surah Hud (Chapter 11 of the Quran) part 1

In the Name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Dispenser of Grace

In Surah Hud (11), we have the stories of the prophets a.s. and their messages to their people...lessons for us to learn.  But more than that, I was struck by the beauty in which the story of the Message that God entrusted to His Messengers developed.  The translation used here is that of Muhammad Asad's.

The Story of Noah a.s.:
(25-26)  And indeed, [it was with the same message that] We sent forth Noah unto his people: "Behold, I come unto you with the plain warning that you may worship none but God - for verily, I fear lest suffering befall you on a grievous Day!"

(27)  But the great ones among his people, who refused to acknowledge the truth, answered: "We do not see in thee anything but a mortal man like ourselves; and we do not see that any follow thee save those who are quite obviously the most abject among us; and we do not see that you could be in any way superior to us: on the contrary, we think you are liars!"

(28-31) Said [Noah]: "O my people! What do you think?  If [it is true that] I am taking my stand on a clear evidence from my Sustainer, who has vouchsafed unto me grace from Himself - [a revelation] to which you have remained blind - : [if this be true,] can we force it on you even though it be hateful to you?  And, O my people, no benefit do I ask of you for this [message]: my reward rests with none but God.  And I shall not repulse [any of] those who have attained to faith.  Verily, they [know that they] are destined to meet their Sustainer, whereas in you I see people without any awareness [of right and wrong]!  And, O my people, who would shield me from God were I to repulse them?  Will you not then, keep this in mind?  And I do not say unto you, 'God's treasures are with me'; nor [do I say], 'I know the reality which is beyond the reach of human perception'; nor do I say, 'Behold I am an angel'; nor do I say of those whom your eyes hold in contempt, 'Never will God grant them any good' - for God is fully aware of what is in their hearts. [Were I to speak thus,] verily, I would indeed be among the evildoers."

Here, the message/warnings given by Noah to his people were:
- worship none but God
- concept of God as Sustainer
- concept of God as the One granting grace
- concept of the meeting with God
- concept of God's knowledge
- not repulse those they think are beneath them
- there was no way for him to force them to accept the message

Clearly, his followers were from the lowest of classes in society and looked down upon.  Yet, these were the people who saw the most clearly the truth while most of his people who felt superior to these low classes were blind to it.

The Story of Hud a.s.:
(50-52)  And unto [the tribe of] 'Ad [We sent] their brother Hud.  He said: "O my people!  Worship God [alone]: you have no deity other than Him.  [As it is,] you are but inventors of falsehood!  O my people!  No reward do I ask of you for this [message]: my reward rests with none but Him who brought me into being.  Will you not, then, use your reason?  Hence, O my people, ask Your Sustainer to forgive you your sins, and then turn towards Him in repentance - [whereupon] He will shower upon you heavenly blessings abundant, and will add strength to your strength: only do not turn away [from me] as people lost in sin!"

(53-54) Said they: "O Hud!  Thou hast brought us no clear evidence [that thou art a prophet]; and we are not going to forsake our gods on thy mere word, the more so as we do not believe thee.  We can say no more than that one of our gods may have smitten thee with something evil!"

(54-57)  Answered [Hud]: "Behold, I call God to witness - and you, too, be [my] witnesses - that, verily, it is not in me to ascribe divinity, as you do, to aught beside Him! Contrive, then, [anything that you may wish] against me, all of you, and give me no respite!  Behold, I have placed my trust in God, [who is] my Sustainer as well as your Sustainer: for there is no living creature which He does not hold by its forelock.  Verily, straight is my Sustainer's way!  But if you choose to turn away, then [know] I have delivered to you the message with which I was sent unto you, and [that] my Sustainer may cause another people to take your place, whereas you will in no wise harm Him.  Verily, my Sustainer watches over all things!"

Here, the same message is repeated and added.  The additions are:
- not to invent falsehood, i.e. 'the attribution of divine qualities to any concrete or imaginary object or person, and the making of false statements about God, His attributes, or the contents of His messages.' (Note 119 of Surah 7 in Muhammad Asad's translation).
- the concept of repentance
- the concept of God as the One who forgives
- the concept of God as the One who everything is dependent on. I.e. 'there is no living being over which He has not complete control and which is not entirely dependent on Him.' (Note 80 of Surah 11)
- the concept of God's straight way
- bearing the consequence of turning away from the message/warnings.

The Story of Salih a.s.:

(61)  And unto [the tribe of] Thamud [We sent] their brother Salih.  He said: "O my people! Worship God [alone]: you have no deity other than Him.  He brought you into being out of the earth, and make you thrive thereon.  Ask Him, therefore, to forgive you your sins, and then turn towards Him in repentance - for, verily, my Sustainer is ever-near, responding [to the call of whoever calls unto Him]!"

(62)  They answered: "O Salih!  Great hopes did we place in thee ere this!  Wouldst thou forbid us to worship what our forefathers were wont to worship?  Because [of this], behold, we are in grave doubt, amounting to suspicion, about [the meaning of] thy call to us!"

(63-64)  He retorted: "O my people!  What do you think?  If [it be true that] I am taking my stand on a clear evidence from my Sustainer, who has vouchsafed unto me grace from Himself - [if this be true,] who would shield me from God were I to rebel against Him?  Hence what you are offering me is no more than perdition!" And [then he said]: "O my people!  This she-camel belonging to God shall be a token for you: so leave her alone to pasture on God's earth, and do her no harm, lest speedy chastisement befall you!"

Again, the same message with more development:
- the concept of God being ever near and responding to those who call unto Him
- the concept of caring for ownerless (possibly stray) animals as quoted in Note 57 of Surah 7:
'The commentators cite various legends to the effect that this she-camel was of miraculous origin.  Since neither the Qur'an nor any authentic Tradition provides the least support for these legends, we must assume that they are based on the expression of naqat Allah (God's she-camel), which has led some pious Muslims to fantastic conjectures.  However, as Rashid Rida points out (Manar VIII, 502), this expression denotes merely the fact that the animal in question was not owned by any one person, and was therefore to be protected by the whole tribe; a further, analogous expression is found in the words 'God's earth' in the same verse: an illustration of the fact that everything belongs to God.  The particular stress by Salih on good treatment of this ownerless animal - referred to in several places in the Qur'an - was obviously due to the cruel high-handedness displayed by the tribe...'